Barkley Dubis

Rick / Muffin Man #1

Julian Sellers

The Pale Man / Julian

Jayden Pettit

Voice of Wither

Cesaire Jose Carroll-Dominguez

Voice of the Businessman / Pete

Syra Ilacqua

Sock

Barry Dubis

Uncle Harry

Eddie Fitzgerald

Muffin Man #2 / Baby

Monte Mandel

Muffin Man #3 / The Rat